Will Jacob Bethell return to England’s side for the Australia ODIs, or will Tom Banton hold on to the opening spot?

England face a top-order selection decision for the first one-day international against Australia in Perth on Friday, with Jacob Bethell back from a knee injury and pushing for a place. The question is whether the 23-year-old returns to the side immediately, and if so, who misses out.

It is a good problem to have. England are still ranked eighth in the world in the 50-over format, and the 2027 Cricket World Cup in South Africa, Zimbabwe and Namibia is less than a year away. Their ODI form has mostly improved this year, until their tri-series trouble in Pakistan in October.

Do England stick with the status quo?

The side looks settled, with three ODIs to come before five T20 internationals. The main decision is at the top of the order. Will Ben Duckett and Tom Banton continue as the opening pair, or will Bethell come straight back in?

Bethell has long been seen as England’s future. He scored a maiden ODI hundred in a win over South Africa to close the 2025 summer, then made further centuries in the fifth Ashes Test in Sydney and the 2026 T20 World Cup semi-final against India.

England moved him up to open for the ODI series against India this summer. He finished it with 91 off 93 balls, part of a 192-run opening stand with Duckett that helped the hosts clinch the series. A knee injury then sidelined him, which gave Banton his chance, and he has taken it. The 27-year-old has averaged 56.28 in seven innings as opener, with four fifties and a superb 126 off 105 balls against Sri Lanka at The Oval.

Duckett and Banton have averaged 71 as a partnership. Duckett ended the tri-series with back-to-back hundreds, his third in his last eight ODIs. Duckett’s place is not in doubt. Banton’s is less certain.

Banton may get another chance, and Bethell may not return straight away. Bethell did not play in the warm-up match against Western Australia at the weekend. Duckett (59) and Banton (14) opened the innings again.

Who else could make way for Bethell?

Bethell may not displace Banton at the top, but he could still play in Australia. Jos Buttler is missing the tour with a hamstring injury. Jordan Cox is expected to take the middle-order spot and keep wicket. England are keen to find a more regular place for Cox, but he did not take his chance in Pakistan. He scored 43 as his top score across four matches, and he did not bat in one of them.

The selectors could drop Cox, move Banton behind the stumps and bring Bethell in. Bethell would add a left-handed option to a middle order otherwise full of right-handers from Joe Root down. Sam Curran, batting at No 6 or 7, is the only exception. Bethell’s inclusion would also give Australian captain Mitch Marsh more problems when setting his field. This route would also delay the Banton and Bethell decision until Buttler returns.

The drawback is that Banton keeping wicket would be unfamiliar across 50 overs, especially while he is also opening. He is a capable understudy and an option behind the stumps in T20 cricket, but it would be a significant ask in ODIs.

What about Bethell as an extra spinner?

This is the least likely route. Bethell first earned his ODI place at No 7, and he offers left-arm spin. However, England played just two spinners in Pakistan. Adil Rashid was left out for much of the tri-series, with Liam Dawson and Will Jacks preferred. If England stick to that approach in the subcontinent, they are unlikely to change it in Australia, or for next year’s World Cup.

Curran’s form and fitness are a concern, though. He missed the end of the summer with a groin injury that needed surgery. In Pakistan he was underused and expensive when he did bowl. He took four wickets at 54.75 across four matches. He bowled only five overs in the first match. In Rawalpindi, he conceded an England ODI-record 103 from nine overs as Sri Lanka chased down a huge 430. He was largely anonymous for the rest of the series.

A break could help Curran rebuild. If that happened, Bethell could benefit, although his batting would be wasted at No 7 or below. England could manage without Curran, with Jofra Archer, Gus Atkinson and Jamie Overton as the pace options. However, dropping Curran would most likely only happen if England wanted to bring Rashid back alongside Dawson and Jacks. In that case, everyone would move up a place, Overton would bat at No 7, and Bethell would again sit on the bench.

England will be glad to have Bethell back, but the bench looks his most likely place in Australia, at least for now.

Schedule for England’s tour of Australia

ODIs start at 3.30am UK time, and T20s at 8.15am UK time.

  • First ODI: Friday, November 13 (Perth)
  • Second ODI: Sunday, November 15 (Adelaide)
  • Third ODI: Wednesday, November 18 (Hobart)
  • First T20I: Saturday, November 21 (Melbourne)
  • Second T20I: Tuesday, November 24 (Carrara)
  • Third T20I: Friday, November 27 (Brisbane)
  • Fourth T20I: Sunday, November 29 (Sydney)
  • Fifth T20I: Wednesday, December 2 (Canberra)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *